Which fireplace should I choose?

How to choose the best fireplace for your space

10 Steps To Choosing The Perfect Setup

Fireplace experts | Twin Cities Minnesota

Step-by-step process

Our expert team has a 10 step process to guide you through planning and executing the perfect project. Bring your vision to life today with our professional fireplace installation team at Glowing Hearth & Home.

Project framework

Define Your
Project Type

Product Selection

Finding Your
Perfect Match

Aesthetic Customization

Create
Your Vision

INstallation planning

Ensure Perfect Execution

Step 1: Identify Your Scenario

Which of these situations best describes your needs?

Replace
an Existing
Fireplace
  • Your current fireplace is outdated, inefficient, or non-functioning
  • You want to upgrade the appearance and performance
  • The unit is approaching or beyond its typical 20 year lifespan
For Fireplace Replacement Projects:
  • Expect full wall opening to access venting and connections
  • Consider upgrading to Kozy Heat for superior flame appearance
  • Use opportunity to refresh stone and mantel elements
  • Typical project requires 1-2 days for fireplace installation plus 1-3 days for stone work
  • Final setup includes media installation and remote programming
  • City inspection typically required between phases
Convert a Wood Fireplace to Gas/Electric
  • You have a traditional masonry wood fireplace
  • You want to eliminate wood cutting, storage, and cleanup
  • You desire improved efficiency and convenience
  • You want to reduce drafts and heat loss
For Wood-to-Gas Conversion Projects:
  • First determine if you have a true masonry fireplace with chimney
  • Schedule free "Preview" service for precise measurements
  • Select insert based on opening dimensions and desired features
  • Consider surround options to cover the gap between insert and opening
  • Chimney cleaning is required before installation
  • Typical project timeline is 2-5 days depending on complexity
Add a
New Fireplace
to a Space
  • You're finishing a basement or remodeling a room and want to add a fireplace
  • You want to add a fireplace where none currently exists
  • You're looking to create a focal point and add warmth to your space
For Basement Fireplace Additions:
  • Determine if gas is available or if electric is preferable
  • For gas: assess venting possibilities (typically horizontal through wall)
  • Consider heat output needs based on room size
  • Select between traditional and linear styles based on wall space
  • Explore stone and mantel options to integrate with room design
  • Ensure proper electrical is installed before walls are closed
Aesthetically Upgrade your fireplace
  • Your existing fireplace works well but looks dated
  • You want to update the surrounding stone, mantel, or facade
  • You're looking to transform the appearance without replacing the unit
For Fireplace Replacement Projects:
  • Expect full wall opening to access venting and connections
  • Consider upgrading to Kozy Heat for superior flame appearance
  • Use opportunity to refresh stone and mantel elements
  • Typical project requires 1-2 days for fireplace installation plus 1-3 days for stone work
  • Final setup includes media installation and remote programming
  • City inspection typically required between phases

Step 2: Define Your Primary Goal

Which of these situations best describes your needs?

Heating Efficiency
  • Primary concern is adding warmth to the space
  • Need to heat a specific square footage effectively
  • Looking for reliable supplemental heating
Visual Appeal/Ambiance
  • Primarily concerned with appearance and visual effect
  • Creating a stunning focal point is the main priority
  • Flame appearance and aesthetics outweigh heating capacity
Convenience & Low Maintenance
  • Seeking simple operation with minimal upkeep
  • Remote control functionality is important
  • Ease of use is a primary consideration
Value & Longevity
  • Looking for the best long-term investment
  • Durability and quality construction are priorities
  • Seeking a solution that will enhance home value

Step 3: Installation Type Determination

Based on your space, what type of installation is appropriate?

Zero Clearance/Direct Vent Installation
  • For adding new fireplaces to spaces
  • When completely replacing an existing fireplace
  • When integrating into wood framing construction
  • When a masonry chimney doesn't exist
Insert Installation
  • When you have an existing masonry fireplace
  • For converting wood-burning fireplaces to gas
  • When working with an existing chimney structure
  • When minimal structural changes are desired
Freestanding Stove
  • When a built-in unit isn't practical
  • For specific aesthetic preferences
  • When more installation flexibility is needed
  • For spaces where a traditional fireplace doesn't fit

Step 4: Technical Feasibility Assessment

What constraints and requirements does your space present?

Venting Possibilities
  • Is exterior wall access available for horizontal venting?
  • Is vertical venting through the roof possible?
  • Are there existing chimney structures to utilize?
  • What clearances exist for venting pathways?
Gas Line Access
  • Is natural gas currently available in the space?
  • How complex would gas line installation be? (Typically around $900)
  • Are there structural barriers to running a gas line?
  • Is propane an alternative if natural gas isn't available?
Electrical Requirements
  • Is electrical access available for fans, lights, and controls?
  • Will new circuits be needed for electric options?
  • Are there smart home integration considerations?
  • What electrical work needs to be completed before wall closing?
Structural Considerations
  • Is the floor rated to support the weight of the unit?
  • Are there adequate clearances for heat-sensitive materials?
  • Will surrounding framing need modification?
  • Are there code requirements specific to your municipality?

Step 5: Fuel Type Selection

Which fuel source best meets your needs and constraints?

Gas Fireplace Benefits
  • Higher heat output (better for primary heating needs)
  • More realistic flame appearance with advanced technology
  • Remote control operation with adjustable settings
  • Requires venting and gas line access
  • Higher installation cost but superior performance
Electric Fireplace Benefits
  • No venting required (maximum installation flexibility)
  • Simple installation ("cut sheetrock and plug in")
  • Lower upfront cost and installation complexity
  • Ideal for bedrooms, basements without gas access
  • Less heat output than gas alternatives
  • Newest technology offers improved visual effects
Wood-Burning Options (if applicable)
  • Most authentic experience
  • Independence from utility services
  • Can be efficient with new insert technology
  • Requires more maintenance and cleaning
  • May affect insurance premiums
  • Not serviced by Glowing Hearth (installation only)

Step 6: Style & Size Determination

What aesthetic direction and dimensions work for your space?

Style Options
  • Traditional: Square-shaped viewing area, classic appearance
  • Linear: Rectangular, wider viewing area, contemporary look
  • See-Through: Visible from multiple rooms
  • Corner: Space-saving installation for room corners
  • Three-Sided: Viewable from multiple angles
Size Considerations
  • Room dimensions and proportion
  • Viewing distance from typical seating
  • Wall space availability (especially for linear models)
  • Ceiling height constraints
  • TV placement requirements (if applicable)
BTU Output Needs
  • Square footage of space to be heated
  • Ceiling height considerations
  • Local climate factors
  • Insulation quality of the space
  • Whether it's primary or supplemental heat

Step 7: Brand & Model Selection

Which specific products deliver your desired combination of features?

Kozy Heat Advantages
  • Flame-Out-of-Log Technology for realistic glow
  • Enhanced lighting & media options
  • Larger size range to accommodate for any project
Heat & Glow Considerations
  • Established brand with long history
  • Conventional burner design (flames from beneath logs)
  • Wide range of style options
  • Well-known name in fireplace industry
Napoleon and Other Options
  • Alternative features and design elements
  • Different price points available
  • Specific models for particular applications

Step 8: Surround & Facing Selection

How will you finish the area around the fireplace?

Stone Options
  • Manufactured stone from partners: Twin City Brick, Hedberg, MSI, Trilite
  • Natural stone selections
  • Color, texture, and pattern variations
  • Full wall applications vs. surround-only
  • Modern vs. traditional appearances
Mantel Considerations
  • Custom wood mantels through Hewn and Forged
  • Stone mantel options through stone suppliers
  • Floating vs. traditional supported designs
  • Size and projection specifications
  • Finish and color selections
  • Proportional relationship to fireplace size
Surround Options
  • For inserts: standard vs. custom surrounds
  • Metal, tile, or stone finishes
  • Sizing to properly cover the gap between insert and opening
  • Decorative details and edge treatments

Step 9: Interior & Media Selection

Log Set Options
  • Traditional oak appearance
  • Birch log styles
  • Driftwood or beach wood effects
  • Split log vs. whole log appearances
  • Charred or natural finishes
Alternative Media
  • Decorative glass in various colors
  • River rock or stone options
  • Crystal or contemporary media
  • Mixed media combinations
Interior Panel Selection
  • Reflective black glass
  • Brick pattern panels
  • Stacked stone appearance
  • Metal or contemporary finishes
  • Herringbone or specialty patterns

Step 10: Lighting & Accessory Options

What enhancements will complete your fireplace experience?

Lighting Elements
  • LED ember bed illumination
  • Downlighting effects
  • Adjustable brightness settings
  • Color options (when available)
Convenience Features
  • Remote control functionality
  • Wall switch options
  • Smart home integration possibilities
  • Programmable settings
Heating Enhancements
  • Fan/blower systems for improved heat circulation
  • Heat zone kits to direct warmth to adjacent rooms
  • Thermostat controls for consistent comfort